Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rona Maynard's avatar

Debbie, I too have suffered from depression and am sorry it has come for you. The question you raise about feedback on your writing has my mind all abuzz.

Writing is lonely work, and it's hard to shake the doubt that anyone cares. I'm on Substack largely for the pleasure of connecting with readers (many of them writers) who appreciate my work and recognize themselves in the stories I tell. Knowing I have readers who look forward to the next post means more than I can say. Then there are all the other people, family members and friends, whose interest in writing is tied to results: a new book getting buzz in the media and a place on bestseller lists. I don't expect them to understand why I write or to take much interest in what I've written. My husband has told me more than once that while he thinks I'm a "brilliant writer," I should stop writing memoir and turn my attention to something more marketable. I have friends who tells me, more than a year after they bought my book, that they haven't read it, as if they fear I am anxiously awaiting their comments. Maybe they'll get to it eventually. But I strongly suspect they won't. They cared enough to help by purchasing the book, but not enough to give it their reading time. I suspect most writers have such friends.

The feedback that keeps me going has to come from the right people, whose minds are attuned to my concerns as a writer. These people don't include my husband or my son. I have a small virtual circle of writer friends who enjoy reading work in progress and will cheer me on. I'm happy to do the same for them. Do you know writers you can ask to read an essay or meet for the occasional Zoom? I'm guessing that you do. And I am here to tell you that it helps.

Expand full comment
Catherine H Palmer's avatar

Oh Debbie! We should be friends. I live in Vermont but visit Stonington most summers...for a week, too short, the place is magical! I imagine myself there through a winter of writing and staring at the foggy ocean. ❤️🦞

But that's not what you asked. I plug away at my newsletter, turning the dials to find an audience, frustrated that I care about progress as measured in numbers. (Still! At 62, measuring my worth by someone else's scale.) If my family reads it, they don't say much, except for my sister who never fails to support me. But my family, even my close friends, are not really the audience I want to reach. I write for a version of myself. The one who seeks, like you, to be [b]older!

P.S. This summer was tough for me. Too hot, too much. Too much self-pressure to write the damn book already, and a list of other projects as long as my arm. And, then, of course, the whole world. 😥I was glum, depressed as well, paralyzed. Digging myself out of it by literally cleaning out my files and folders, tossing out lists of what I should be doing, and asking this question every day in my morning pages: What life do you really want? ❤️☘️

Expand full comment
74 more comments...

No posts