Behind The Scenes with Steven Petrow
The bestselling author talks about how his sister, Julie Petrow, chose to end her life using Medical Aid In Dying
🎙️ Listen to this episode: Steven Petrow on His Sister Julie, the Importance of Choice, and Medical Aid in Dying
I first got to know Steven Petrow almost three years ago, when he came on the podcast to talk about his bestselling book: Stupid Things I Won't Do When I Get Old: A Highly Judgmental, Unapologetically Honest Accounting of All the Things Our Elders Are Doing Wrong1. He’s a lovely guest, eloquent, respectful, and informed. And I loved his Stupid Things, which had me howling.
When I saw his startling essay about his sister’s death in The New York Times2 several months ago, using MAID (medical aid in dying), I wanted him to come back on the show. I know a little bit about MAID through my husband
, who is a now-retired physician. Sam has told me how difficult it can be for the families of patients who choose to die this way. Nothing about end-of-life is easy or simple, he says.“On the day before my sister Julie died, I lay down on her bed and held her gingerly in my arms, afraid that any pressure would hurt her. She had lost so much weight that she looked like a stick figure I might have drawn when we were kids. As her body had wasted, her tumors had grown — now several of them bigger than baseballs. Her abdomen looked like the lunar landscape, with protrusions everywhere, the sources of her pain plainly visible.” - Steven Petrow (The New York Times, Dec. 28, 2023)
After years of battling ovarian cancer, Steven’s adored five-years-younger sister Julie chose to die in her New Jersey home in June of 2023 by drinking a lethal cocktail. She was surrounded by her family. And it was legal, as she used a procedure called MAID or medical aid in dying, which is now legal in 10 states in the U.S. plus the District of Columbia.
But before she died, she made Steven, who is a bestselling author and a contributing columnist for The Washington Post, PROMISE to write about how she chose to die. Why? In order to raise awareness around MAID, a practice that many people don’t know about, or don’t understand, even though it was first legalized in Oregon, almost 30 years ago.
So Steven did, publishing the essay about Julie and her decision in The New York Times. The essay got a huge reception and stirred interest, conversation, and over 600 comments.
In this episode, Steven explains more:
What the term medical aid in dying means3 and what it is exactly (it used to be called physician assisted suicide, but a physician is NOT present)
Why he thinks only 9,000 people have availed themselves of the procedure since it first became legalized
Why it’s mostly used by educated whites (for one thing, the cocktail of lethal drugs cost $700 to $900 and is NOT reimbursable)
This is simply a fascinating episode and I hope you’ll listen to it.
Please share your thoughts about MAID
If you are comfortable talking about it, I invite you to share your thoughts about MAID. Do you have any firsthand experience?
… calling all [B]old Women
As some of you may have heard, I’ve decided to host an online home for [B]old Women. By that I mean women writers on Substack who are in their 60s, 70s, and 80s. Those in their 40s and 50s are welcome as well. It’s a work in progress but, if that’s you, I’d love you to introduce yourself in my most recent post and let me know any ideas or feedback you have on this burgeoning community—what you’d like to see, how you’d like to participate, etc. - Debbie
Stupid Things I Won't Do When I Get Old: A Highly Judgmental, Unapologetically Honest Accounting of All the Things Our Elders Are Doing Wrong by Steven Petrow (Citadel; June 29, 2021)
I Promised My Sister I Would Write About How She Chose to Die by Steven Petrow (The New York Times, Dec. 28, 2023)
Definition of Medical Aid in Dying
I am interested in this process and have mixed feelings but overall I know that death comes for us all and I am grateful for this opportunity to spread awareness if this is the way you wish to leave this life. I have my mantra from 20 yrs in eldercare that death is inevitable but suffering doesn't have to be...our society has become the product of confusion and more pain at times..forcing their thoughts beliefs and judgements on individuals who aren't able or willing to make their wishes heard..have these conversations well before you lose your right to decide...it's the most loving thing you can do...sadly most will refuse to talk about end of life because it's too painful..ie...to let mom go...but much suffering could be avoided if boundaries had been clearly set..and DONT VILLIFY NURSING HOMES!!..they are a lovely place to be if you take time to visit and volunteer and see the the improved overall quality of care and awesome people that are your best source of real time answers and if you plan it early enough you can write your own desired experience and make the best of the rest of your last phase of life...I would not trade my time with these precious souls for it was so ...valuable and life affirming!
Around the same time my sister was the caregiver for her MIL with Alzheimer’s I had to put down our dog who was in pain, peeing and pooing on himself, unable to walk and not going to heal. Giving our dog a lethal dose of whatever chemical was humane. My sister suggested that it was inhumane to allow her MIL to live in a similar way. I know several people who went thru horrific illnesses with a parent with no options.
MAID sounds like an important alternative. The thought that we treat our dogs more humanely doesn’t make sense. And yes, I believe in G-d.
Looking forward to listening to the podcast.